Lacartes.com
  • Businesses
    • Businesses
    • Marketplace
    • Jobs
    • Photos
    • Videos
  • Local Businessess
  • Marketplace
  • Jobs
  • Community
  • LOG IN
  • SIGNUP
Home
 >
Business
 >
United States
 >
Bay Shore
 >
Captain Bill's Restaurant & Catering

Captain Bill's Restaurant & Catering

  • FOLLOW
  • WRITE REVIEW
  • SEND MESSAGE
  • Profile
  • Photos6
  • Pricelists5

View Our Prices

Menus & Prices, Captain Bill's Restaurant & Catering, Bay Shore
Menus & Prices, Captain Bill's Restaurant & Catering, Bay Shore
Menus & Prices, Captain Bill's Restaurant & Catering, Bay Shore
Menus & Prices, Captain Bill's Restaurant & Catering, Bay Shore

Latest Photos

Captain Bill's Restaurant & Catering, Bay Shore
Captain Bill's Restaurant & Catering, Bay Shore
Captain Bill's Restaurant & Catering, Bay Shore
Captain Bill's Restaurant & Catering, Bay Shore

Introduction

The History of Captain Bill's
The history of Captain Bill's dates back to the late 1920's when there was a simple 24' by 24' wooden structure standing at the foot of Ocean Avenue and run by the Boatmen's Association. Fishing party boats were run out of the building. One of the original boatmen, Captain Bill Eccleston would travel to neighboring towns selling fish and clams, blowing a bugle horn to announce his presence. Captain Bill was a legend in the area and quite a salty character. He eventually bought the wooden structure, started a small clam bar and named it after himself.

Captain Bill sold the clam bar in the early 1950's to Sophie and Carl Abendroth who eventually renovated the building and built what is now the main restaurant. In the late 1950's, Carl and Sophie purchased the building next door as a catering hall, calling it the Anchorage. In 1982 Carl Anton purchased the marina, restaurant and catering hall, however the property was put into receivership in the late 1980's. After several attempts by different groups to turn Captain Bill's into a successful business, its doors were shut for several years until a local real estate investor, Lou Modica, purchased the property.

In 1998, current owners, Peter McCarthy and Michael Korb, approached Modica about reopening the historic landmark. After a multimillion dollar renovation, Captain Bill's reopened its doors in June of 1998. One year later, the Anchorage was renovated and renamed The Bayview House, accommodating larger parties and waterfront weddings. After 13 successful years, Peter and Michael continue to manage and direct the day to day operations at this historic waterfront landmark, employing 100+ local staff.

About Us
Prior to reopening Captain Bill's, Peter McCarthy and Michael Korb had worked together for 14 years for a local Long Island restaurant and catering company as the vice president and corporate chef, respectively. With extensive backgrounds in the food and beverage industry with companies such as Westin International and Marriott Hotels, Peter and Michael have had the pleasure in operating many diverse restaurants, from casual to fine dining as well as catering functions such as the U.S. Polo Open, tented weddings and annual functions up to 3,000 guests. Peter and Michael, both having lived locally for most of their lives, embarked on the journey of reestablishing Captain Bill's as the premiere restaurant and catering facility that it once was.

Now, heading into their thirteenth year of business, Peter and Michael take pride and satisfaction in having provided growth and income opportunities for hundreds of current and former employees. They also take satisfaction in having provided a venue that friends and families have been able to gather for an enjoyable evening whether in our dining room or bar, or in one of our catering rooms.

We look forward to seeing you here at Captain Bill's soon!

Contact Info

Address:
122 Ocean Avenue
Bay Shore
New York 11706
United States
Tel:
(631)665-6262
Website:
http://www.captainbills.com

Offering

  • Sea Food
  • Catering
  • Weddings

Hours of operation

From To From To From To
MondayOpen
TuesdayOpen
WednesdayOpen
ThursdayOpen
FridayOpen
SaturdayOpen
SundayOpen

CATEGORIES IN BAY SHORE

Bay Shore Restaurants  ·  Bay Shore Caterers  ·  Bay Shore Bars & Pubs  ·  Bay Shore Financial & Investment Advice  ·  Bay Shore Mortgage Brokers  ·  Bay Shore Cafe  ·  Bay Shore Cleaners  ·  Bay Shore Skin Care  ·  Bay Shore Carpet Cleaning  ·  Bay Shore Internet Marketing & SEO Services  ·  Bay Shore Servicing & Repair  ·  Bay Shore Legal Contracts  ·  Bay Shore Business Support Services

SIMILAR BUSINESSES NEARBY

Molly Malone's Pub & Restaurant
Bay Shore
Tel: 631-969-2232
fatfish Wine Bar & Bistro
Bayshore
Tel: 631-662-2899
Nicky's Clam Bar
Bay Shore
Tel: 631-665-6621
Coastal Kitchen & Daiquiri Bar
Bay Shore
Tel: 631-665-3030
Verde Kitchen & Cocktails
Bay Shore
Tel: (631) 665-6300
Milk and Sugar Cafe
Bay Shore
Tel: (631) 969-3655
Tula Kitchen
Bay Shore
Tel: 631 539 7183
Tula Kitchen
Bay Shore
Tel: 631 539 7183
The Lake House Restaurant
Bay Shore
Tel: (631) 666-0995
Declan Quinn's Restaurant
Bay Shore
Tel: (631)206-2006

SEARCH TAGS

Captain Bill's Restaurant & Catering · Sea Food · Sea Food · Catering · Weddings · Captain Bill's Restaurant & Catering 11706 · Sea Food 11706 · Sea Food 11706 · Catering 11706 · Weddings 11706 · Captain Bill's Restaurant & Catering Bay Shore · Sea Food Bay Shore · Sea Food Bay Shore · Catering Bay Shore · Weddings Bay Shore · United States Restaurants · United States Caterers · New York Restaurants · New York Caterers · Bay Shore Restaurants · Bay Shore Caterers
NEWS FEEDS
  • Tarika Group listed on Lacartes
    14 Apr 2026
  • Eaton Fire Legal Team listed on Lacartes
    13 Apr 2026
  • Roxell Richards Injury Law Firm listed on Lacartes
    13 Apr 2026
  • Tess House Law listed on Lacartes
    13 Apr 2026
  • Amazing Morrow listed on Lacartes
    10 Apr 2026
See More

Email Captain Bill's Restaurant & Catering

Do not send job enquiries or promotional messages via this form. Non-genuine enquiries can result in you being blocked from the site.
Your Name:*
Your Email:*
Re-enter Email:*
Your Contact Tel:*
Subject:*
Your query:*
Please do not use rude language. Messages containing any rude language will be automatically deleted.

Review Captain Bill's Restaurant & Catering

Review Rules
  • No spam, self-promotion or offensive language.
  • Write as if telling a good friend about your experience.
  • Describe the products or services you received and justify your rating.
  • Reviews like 'This is great!' 'Terrible business! Avoid!' will be removed.
Your Rating*
Title*
Your Review*
Email*
Tel*
Name*
Add up to 10 photos to support your review
Accepted file format: jpg, png
Max file size: 10mb
This website is best viewed using the latest Internet Explorer, Chrome, Safari, Firefox and other web browsers.

Locations

  • United Kingdom
  • Philippines
  • United States
  • India
  • Ireland
  • New Zealand
  • Australia
  • Canada
  • Romania
  • Singapore
  • Luxembourg
  • Spain
  • Germany
  • France
  • China
  • Croatia
  • South Africa
  • Hungary
  • Italy
  • Slovakia

Categories

  • Professional Services
  • Home Improvement
  • Health
  • Food & Drink
  • Shopping
  • Finance & Insurance
  • Health Products
  • Manufacturers & Industrial
  • Automotive
  • Legal

Marketplace

  • Health & Beauty
  • Business & Industrial
  • Clothing & Accessories
  • Furniture
  • Electronics
  • Home & Garden
  • Vehicles & Parts
  • Hardware
  • Arts & Entertainment
Lacartes.com © all rights reserved  |  About  |  Business Solutions  |  Contact  |  Terms  |  Privacy
Cookies help us deliver our services. By using this Site you consent to our use of cookies. OK Learn more
FREE SIGN UP
LOGIN TO LACARTES
Already have an account? Log in
Forgot password?
Don't have an account? Sign up
By clicking sign up you confirm you have read and agreed to our terms of service and privacy policy
Please disable Adblock on Lacartes.com

Seems adblock is enabled on your browser. We do NOT use pop-up ads and the subtle ad on each page helps keep Lacartes.com completely and permanently free.

In addition, Adblock can sometimes block essential pop-ups that are part of the website’s function such as pop-up registration or contact forms.

Please support us by disabling adblock on lacartes.com. We are grateful for your understanding and co-operation!